Forum home Plants
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

ROSES Autumn/Winter Season 2021/22

1160161163165166253

Posts

  • cooldoccooldoc Posts: 853
    edited February 2022
    @Jemula thanks for the detailed description :) You have a wonderful collection of old roses.. Indigo appears a bit darker compared to others.. And suckering of RdR/ Indigo was mentioned by others as well.. guess Portlands sucker on their own root..
    edited to add that my CdC had to be left behind when we moved as it was balling badly for me...
     
    thanks @Marlorena @edhelka for the pics.. Amanda P has a peculiar arrangement of petals and colour variation as well..

    I feel much better (less guilty) after all the stats :# I've got around 40, all in pots... will give the exact count tomorrow...
    A rose lover from West midlands
  • FireFire Posts: 19,096
    Jemula said:
    Yolande has the most delicious old rose fragrance of any rose

    Perhaps it's similar to Dr Jamain, although it tends to green apple scent. It needs extra TLC and I'm always interested to see it to make rosarians' 'top roses' lists.
  • edhelkaedhelka Posts: 2,351
    cooldoc said:
    Amanda P has a peculiar arrangement of petals and colour variation as well..
    An old reference describing Joasine Hanet (1913):
    An odd-shaped Rose of peculiar color, cultivated by enthusiasts because of its eccentricities. The flowers are of medium size and strangely formed, with the appearance of having been quartered. In color they are deep rose, tinged with violet- a shading as distinctive as is the shape of the blossom. The fragrance is very strong. The plant is of luxuriant growth, with long shoots, and thrives well in temperate climates.

    Another one (1892):
    Hybrid Remontant. Belongs to the old Portland group. Deep rose, tinged with violet, medium size, full, quartered shape; fragrant, very hardy a profuse bloomer. The color and form are bad, and destroy its usefulness.

    That's the main reason why I believe that the rose sold today as Amanda Patternote (various spellings) is Joasine Hanet.
    Not everyone agrees on this but the original Amanda's blooms were described as "deep pink, large, double/full, globular" - and this certainly isn't the case.

    Both original Amanda and Joasine are sister seedlings (having the same mother, the famous and lost Belle de Trianon). Another two well-known sister seedlings of them are Sidonie and Jolande d'Aragon.

    A found rose common in the USA, Portland from Glendora, was identified as Joasine Hanet. This is mostly accepted but some rose experts disagree or have doubts.

    I like to call my rose 'Glendora' because I like the name and I believe they are all the same rose - the original Joasine - although the modern clones maybe drifted away from the original a bit. The original Joasine is supposed to have a bit more magenta/violet in it.


  • FireFire Posts: 19,096
    edited February 2022
    Find myself reacding articles from Country Life. Oh dear. Has it really come to this? Charles Quest-Ritson (writer of RHS Encyclopedia of Roses) states " there’s a good reason why so many florists’ roses are scentless: the gene for scent is incompatible with the gene for a long vase life and cut-flower roses". He lists Munstead Wood as one of the best ever roses for scent. It's an interesting article.

    But from what I read about Charles QR, he does seem like a twonk.




  • MarlorenaMarlorena Posts: 8,705
    @newbie77
    I am probably more shocked at your totals than any other...  all those DA's, I had no idea..   more photos please this summer... 
    East Anglia, England
  • newbie77newbie77 Posts: 1,838
    I was surprised with Omori's and Tack's numbers. 

    Yes we need more photos from everyone and I should post more photos too.
    South West London
  • FireFire Posts: 19,096
    .... and you might need to change your user name ;)
Sign In or Register to comment.