Forum home Plants
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

Plants that root in water

1414244464759

Posts

  • PeggyTXPeggyTX Posts: 556
    Helen P3 said:
    PeggyTX said:

    .... I have absolutely no problem rooting it by two-leaf pair cuttings in direct in dirt.       
    Is that hygienic?   ;)
    ???  @Helen P3, can you please expand on your comment?  I don't see how/why sticking a plant cutting in dirt is 'unhygienic'.  Gardeners around the world have been propagating plants that way for ages.  What am I not understanding here? 
    My low-carb recipe site: https://buttoni.wordpress.com/
  • LynLyn Posts: 23,190
    Peggy I think the poster  assumes you put your cuttings in the stuff you get out of your vacuum cleaner, that’s what  the U.K. call dirt.
    Some of us are posh and call it compost.😀

    Gardening on the wild, windy west side of Dartmoor. 

  • As Lyn and coccinella have explained, the latter at some length, here in Britain, the word "dirt" has an entirely different meaning. 

    I suspect, Helen was lightly teasing; as evidenced by her emoji?

    https://dictionary.cambridge.org/

    dirt

    noun [ no plural ]

    UK 

     /dɜːt/

     

    B1

    substance that makes something not clean:

    You’ve got some dirt on your trousers.

    (Definition of dirt from the Cambridge Essential Dictionary © Cambridge University Press)

     

    soil

    noun

    UK 

     

     /sɔɪl/ US 

     /sɔɪl/

     

    the material on the surface of the ground in which plants grow:

    light/heavy/fertile soil

    sandy or chalky soils

     picture of soil

    ©fitopardo.com/Moment/GettyImages

     

    [ U ] literary

    country:

    It was the first time we had set foot on foreign/French/American soil (= gone to a foreign country/France/America). 
  • Sam 37Sam 37 Posts: 1,271
    blime me
  • delskidelski Posts: 274
    edited July 2021
    The UK/american thing has always perplexed me. We Irish/scots/welsh/english went to America and colonised the natives, therefore becoming/creating americans as we know today, yet we created a bunch of people who don't understand their origins, don't understand our accents or the different english words that we all use but most british people understand them as a result of the constant bombardement of american media in the form of "movies" or films but they don't get the same of us in return.
    Brits know that a diaper is a nappy. We know that a pacifier is a dummy. We know that a faucet is a tap. So why the BEEP don't you americans know that in reverse?! That is a limited example of my exasperation: there are many more examples of such ridiculousness.
  • Mr. Vine EyeMr. Vine Eye Posts: 2,394
    edited July 2021
    @delski 😂😂 

    We Irish/scots/welsh/english went to America and colonised the natives
    Oh we did, did we!? You’d think I’d remember something like that!

    You’ve just answered your own question - We know because of US media - movies/tv shows etc.

    It’s not the same the other way around. 

    Language changes/evolves over time and obviously varies by geographical separation. Getting exasperated with someone in the US for not knowing a British term is as silly as getting exasperated with someone in this country not fully understanding Chaucer.

    also remember that we live in a relatively small country and yet have a huge amount of variation with different accents and dialects.

    Good example, I have a coworker from Northumberland area and she has several expressions that I don’t understand! There’s been a few times when I’ve not fullY understood what she was saying and she’s had to explain. But it was funny and nice to learn a new expression.

    It’s just variation in language and we can’t know it all! 

    Do you think the modern inhabitants of Saxony and Denmark curse us for altering their words and not bothering to know theirs?

    Certainly not something to get “BEEP”ing about 🤣
    East Yorkshire
  • Zoe P2Zoe P2 Posts: 848
    edited July 2021

    It’s not the same the other way around. 

     Getting exasperated with someone in the US for not knowing a British term ....



    Over the years, I have known a considerable number of Americans, as I lived there briefly and worked with some of them in England.

    I never met one who didn't understand that to the British the word for soil is SOIL..... 

    I, therefore, looked at other posts of this American poster, whom I don't recall ever encountering before, and this is what I found:


    PeggyTX
     
    Posts: 546

    30 May

    I cut off an out-of-control, 2' long leaf from my Sanseveria plant, cut into 6 pieces and poked into a pot of soil.  Need to replace the 6 I lost ….




    I have a dream that my.. children.. one day.. will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character

      Martin Luther King

  • Mr. Vine EyeMr. Vine Eye Posts: 2,394
    @Zoe P2 - I think you've missed the point of my post.

    Which was to say that getting 'exasperated' and saying things like 'Why the BEEP don't you Americans...' - over a linguistical distance is OTT.

    East Yorkshire
  • Zoe P2Zoe P2 Posts: 848
    ... the point of my post

     was to say that getting 'exasperated' ... is OTT.

    Perhaps we're all different and react differently; but, facts are facts?  :)



    I have a dream that my.. children.. one day.. will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character

      Martin Luther King

  • honeybeanhoneybean Posts: 50
    B3 said:

    This year, I discovered how easily penstemons root in water.

    A few weeks ago, I took some more cuttings. I rooted them and potted them up.

    One looked a bit more whispy than the others and  a few buds had developed. I planted them out a few days ago and lo and behold - a white gaura!

    So that's two kinds. I've seen on another post that coleus roots and I know busy lizzies will root.

    In my experience, dianthus and geraniums won't.

    Can anyone add to my list of rooters?

    Geraniums, Pelargoniums, Sedum and Tradescantia 
    Thanks 🌻
Sign In or Register to comment.