Forum home Problem solving
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

Compost not composting

2

Posts

  • FireFire Posts: 19,096
    edited May 2022
    It depends what you put in the mix. If it's all very small non-woody prunings and kitchen waste and paper, I can get good compost in three months in a rubbish bin without turning much. The bigger the pieces, the long it takes. A sealed bin (with drainage holes) holds in the heat and the moisture. As I'm adding bits from the garden - plus a bit of soil, and manure (if I have it), the compost is packed with worms and bugs and fungi that speed up the process. Like sour dough, add a dollop of your last finished compost to your next bin to get it going. A low rubbish bin (with a lid) makes it easy to empty and turn. They cost about £10. My bins are in a sheltered spot against a shed, on the ground, so that will help keep them a bit warmer. 

    I don't really turn them. Once during a cycle, I empty the contents from one bin to another, to aerate and finish off. At that point, I add more of what might be needed - paper/wood chip to dry things out or greens/water to moisten things up.
  • OldcompostOldcompost Posts: 191
    Thank you everyone again, in hindsight I should have asked the builders to leave a gap of 4 paving stones.

    Fire & Posy: The mix has already been removed, sifted and put back 5 times but I will add some earth and commercial compost.
    Butterfly66: They were originally standing on large plastic trays but the rain collected in them, also, small daily amounts of used hay with the chicken poo was added but no twigs that would take longer to break down.
    Fairygirl: Until this year the larger bin produced perfect compost by April.

    The most successful year was 2018 when adding several large bags of seaweed and 3 year old leaf mould made the seedlings grow 30% faster and produced 40% more tomatoes alongside identical pots using John Innes No3.   
  • Chris-P-BaconChris-P-Bacon Posts: 943
    To be honest, I think they're too small.
    You'll get compost eventually but it will be quite a small amount in the end.
    The bigger the heap the more 'activity' it will create. It wont necessarily heat up - domestic heaps quite often don't - but you'll get more fungal activity.
    I think one or two 'dalek' type bins would be more useful. 
  • OldcompostOldcompost Posts: 191
    Chris-P-Bacon:  My friends have bigger gardens and their proper heaps really heat up whereas my bins never have.  However, I've heard cold composting eventually produces a richer mix and the commercial bags are 'steamed' for sterilisation purposes which kills off the weeds but also reduces the goodness.   
  • FairygirlFairygirl Posts: 55,117
    If you had success with a bigger bin, why did you change? Have you just not got room now? Is there anywhere else you can site a bigger bin? 
    It's a place where beautiful isn't enough of a word....



    I live in west central Scotland - not where that photo is...
  • OldcompostOldcompost Posts: 191
    Fairygirl: If you look at the 2 photos, last year I had my garden improved with a shed/cabin taking priority.  The builders then filled in the gaps with gravel paths, paving plus fruit & veg cages and the space for compost bins got overlooked. 
  • FairygirlFairygirl Posts: 55,117
    Is there room in the corner by the shed? How about purpose built, long bins, along the fence where you have the current ones? That would give you more capacity. 
    Your fruit/veg/greenhouse area is lovely - bigger than my entire garden  :D
    It's a place where beautiful isn't enough of a word....



    I live in west central Scotland - not where that photo is...
  • OldcompostOldcompost Posts: 191
    Fairygirl:  No room anywhere.  I'll look into having long ones built as per your suggestion, thanks for that. 
  • Thank you everyone again, in hindsight I should have asked the builders to leave a gap of 4 paving stones.

    Fire & Posy: The mix has already been removed, sifted and put back 5 times but I will add some earth and commercial compost.
    Butterfly66: They were originally standing on large plastic trays but the rain collected in them, also, small daily amounts of used hay with the chicken poo was added but no twigs that would take longer to break down.
    Fairygirl: Until this year the larger bin produced perfect compost by April.

    The most successful year was 2018 when adding several large bags of seaweed and 3 year old leaf mould made the seedlings grow 30% faster and produced 40% more tomatoes alongside identical pots using John Innes No3.   

    Why add commercial compost?
  • OldcompostOldcompost Posts: 191
    StephenSouthwest: Sorry typo, well spotted - previous finished compost not commercial.  We live in Devon which must be close to you?  
Sign In or Register to comment.