This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.
Rose recommendation - single/small-flowered climber
After being inspired by the rose thread on this forum, I've decided I'd like to plant a rose to cover my south-facing wall.
I've never grown a rose, so would appreciate advice on which to choose. I'd prefer single or small flowered roses, to create a woodland/wild rose feeling, in pale white/cream/yellow shades. My next priorities are fragrance, plus shapely lighter-coloured foliage. I'm also wondering if I might have space for two roses.
- Malvern hills (this is top of my list at the moment as it seems to tick all my boxes and many have commented on its foliage, but I wonder how much scent it has and how long it really flowers for)
- Bobbie James (this is reputed to be a monster, but I haven't found similar roses on a smaller scale. Even though it is once-flowering, I love the elegance of its simple blooms, plus there are some rave reviews about its scent (on this site, in German so you'll have to use the browser translate software, https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/kletterrosen/bobbie-james?c=189)
- Goldfinch (once-flowering, but rated highly to slightly scented on different sites)
- R. Moschata (a wild rose descendant that is late-blooming and rated strongly scented, but I'm not sure what musk smells like!)
The wall dimensions are 310cm at the highest point and about 7m across - measured from the top of a 30 cm high raised bed I will create in front of it (about 1m wide, and open to the ground). This is to improve the soil, as it's a bit rocky/stony with the wall foundations.




I've never grown a rose, so would appreciate advice on which to choose. I'd prefer single or small flowered roses, to create a woodland/wild rose feeling, in pale white/cream/yellow shades. My next priorities are fragrance, plus shapely lighter-coloured foliage. I'm also wondering if I might have space for two roses.
- Malvern hills (this is top of my list at the moment as it seems to tick all my boxes and many have commented on its foliage, but I wonder how much scent it has and how long it really flowers for)
- Bobbie James (this is reputed to be a monster, but I haven't found similar roses on a smaller scale. Even though it is once-flowering, I love the elegance of its simple blooms, plus there are some rave reviews about its scent (on this site, in German so you'll have to use the browser translate software, https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/kletterrosen/bobbie-james?c=189)
- Goldfinch (once-flowering, but rated highly to slightly scented on different sites)
- R. Moschata (a wild rose descendant that is late-blooming and rated strongly scented, but I'm not sure what musk smells like!)
The wall dimensions are 310cm at the highest point and about 7m across - measured from the top of a 30 cm high raised bed I will create in front of it (about 1m wide, and open to the ground). This is to improve the soil, as it's a bit rocky/stony with the wall foundations.

1
Posts
Gardening in Central Norfolk on improved gritty moraine over chalk ... free-draining.
The dentelles are once blooming .
But they are on my wishlist .. 😉
@Fire, Moonlight is beautiful - I had discounted shrub roses (like the wonderful Kew Gardens), but I see now it possibly grows to 2.5m. If you grow it, could you describe its scent?
@Dovefromabove FE Lester would go very well with the apple tree from next door since David Austin says it resembles apple blossom, but I'm not sure about the pink margins.
@lpayres3 Sally Holmes is pretty too but also seems like it could have pink edges.
@Imprevu Hello - so nice to "meet" someone else in Belgium! Thanks for the tip - I have spent far too much time browsing the Lens website, and might even order my roses from there (:
@Cambridgerose12 Snow Goose is actually on my list (: I did not mention it because it's not a tall climber, but it's a rose I've always wanted to grow, and will have in addition to a "proper" climber to cover as much of the wall as I can.
A wonderful rose as Dove says and very pretty.
You don't notice the edges on the flowers and they turn white by the time they're open.
A grand show of autumn hips too
PS - sadly it had to go, but I replaced it with The Garland -
Billericay - Essex
Knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit.
Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad.