Forum home Plants
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

Is our Photinia Red Robin tree ok?

davebettzdavebettz Posts: 110
Hi my dad mentioned our red robin tree didn't look too good? It flowered in April/may and has since dropped all it's leaves.

It's been potted since the start of the year.
«1

Posts

  • Paul B3Paul B3 Posts: 3,154
    When you say its been potted , I would have thought a shrub/tree of that size would be struggling to intake enough water .
    With recent warm drying winds , your plant would have been unable to transpire at a pace to compensate .
    A second possible reason is Fireblight disease (I hope not) which affects members of the rose family ; symptoms include an apparent scorching of the leaves combined with leaf-curl ; exfoliation is then rapid and the plant normally dies .
    I lost a large specimen once ; it was growing in a moist position so drought wasn't responsible .
    I blame the above , (Fireblight) .

  • davebettzdavebettz Posts: 110
    Paul B3 said:
    When you say its been potted , I would have thought a shrub/tree of that size would be struggling to intake enough water .
    With recent warm drying winds , your plant would have been unable to transpire at a pace to compensate .
    A second possible reason is Fireblight disease (I hope not) which affects members of the rose family ; symptoms include an apparent scorching of the leaves combined with leaf-curl ; exfoliation is then rapid and the plant normally dies .
    I lost a large specimen once ; it was growing in a moist position so drought wasn't responsible .
    I blame the above , (Fireblight) .

    My sister also has the same trees we got them from a showhome site,she planted hers in the front and there's have done the same as our potted tree??
  • davebettzdavebettz Posts: 110
    edited June 2019
    The branches are still green underneath

  • Paul B3Paul B3 Posts: 3,154
    edited June 2019
    It could be a combination of reasons ; last years long hot dry-spell maybe manifesting itself this year .
    When you got them from a showhome site , had they been looked after properly?
    Nursery grown plants are often raised in controlled conditions , then exposed to the elements outdoors , which can be a shock to the system to say the least .
    It may also be possible the plants were imported specimens ; if Dutch they would have been raised in near-perfect conditions (as they do) , then as I said above exposure outdoors might have taken its toll .


  • AnniDAnniD Posts: 12,585
    I must admit the first photo of the leaf looked like fireblight to me, the 2nd looks like a type of fungal  infection. The fact that all the trees have done the same thing makes me wonder if they were affected before they were planted, it's a bit of a coincidence .
    I agree it would be better off in the ground than a pot. How long have you and your sister had them? Were her's planted in the ground straight away ?
  • Paul B3Paul B3 Posts: 3,154
    My specimen Photinia (Stranvaesia) davidiana 'Palette' died last year showing similar symptoms ; a catastrophic loss to me as it was  thirty+ years old ; a sad loss .
  • davebettzdavebettz Posts: 110
    Just checked and we've had them since last summer August. I can't plant it in the ground as we've drainage pipes underneath where it currently is.

    Sister planted hers in the ground straight away,she's saying hers are fine actually

  • AnniDAnniD Posts: 12,585
    Well, that's something, at least her's are okay. I am stuck to be honest,  as Paul says it may well be fireblight. Have a look at this info from the RHS 
    https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=160
  • davebettzdavebettz Posts: 110
    AnniD said:
    Well, that's something, at least her's are okay. I am stuck to be honest,  as Paul says it may well be fireblight. Have a look at this info from the RHS 
    https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=160
    Had a quick look so the only thing I can really do is try and trim it back?
  • craigbeckcraigbeck Posts: 8
    edited June 2019
    Did you feed it? That pot is a little small and the nutrients would have been taken up after a while - I'm assuming that last picture is an old picture.
    I would get a bigger pot and lightly feed it when needed, every 4-6 month.
    But that original pic looks a lot sad, here's hoping and crossing fingers but hope is low, sorry.
Sign In or Register to comment.