This is how I view it- it is what it is a look at French Gardens from a visitors point of view -not an instructional video on how to grow-I doubt anyone visits Kew or Wisley looking for advice just to admire- that is what this programme is- a travelogue on French Gardens.
As for presenters this has been discussed here and elsewhere-I understand why a dislike is taken to some -not keen on Carole Klein-too gushy (sorry sacrilege broken) Alys Fowler too prissy-doesn't worry me much that a tool is thrown on the floor- we have all done that
I think with TB an experiment was made to make gardening the in-thing with a new audience it was not a complete failure after all-but you live with the presenter we have-MD will move on at some point
Beechgrove is more of a practical programme so with that and GW they will compliment not rival each other.
I agree Geoff. I watched just for the sheer plearsure of seeing a beautiful garden, whether it is to my taste or not. I admire the hard work and vision that has gone into the making of them. If you learn something along the way, all the better.
I agree too. There are too few gardening programmes (or even programmes about gardens) to moan about them when they come along. I prefer to just enjoy.
Au contraire - there are so few gardening programmes that the ones we have should be done well, from the initial idea to the setting of budgets, choosing of camera teams and editors, researching the gardens or subjects to be visited and final presentation. Monty's French Gardens is going out in a Friday night gardening slot so should be more than pretty pictures and a travelogue slapped together any old how. It should have some metaphorical gardening meat to it.
Vendée - 20kms from Atlantic coast.
"The price good men (and women) pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men (and women)."
I've really enjoyed it so far - and Monty looks as though he's enjoying himself as well. I think it's a pity that there are so few things on TV about gardens - whether those to visit, or one's own garden and what to do/how to do it. I think there's room for more gardening related programmes, especially as there are so many TV channels these days - so can only conclude that The Powers That Be don't agree.
So... I know nothing and would like to suprise she who must be obeyed... Is there an idiot link or can someone point me in the direction of where each of these gardens are (Excluding Paris) so I can try and work it into my French holiday and become a god amongst men
So... I know nothing and would like to suprise she who must be obeyed... Is there an idiot link or can someone point me in the direction of where each of these gardens are (Excluding Paris) so I can try and work it into my French holiday and become a god amongst men
Thanks in advance
Bit of a tall order-there is a book coming out -but not till April
There was a map of all the gardens in the GW magazine (Feb edition) - you might find one still in the shops. There are a group in Provence and another group in Normany and then the collection round Paris (Versailles et al).
Posts
Sasha - I slept thru it
Again BJay
. I've recorded them and still haven't got around to watching the first one yet 
This is how I view it- it is what it is a look at French Gardens from a visitors point of view -not an instructional video on how to grow-I doubt anyone visits Kew or Wisley looking for advice just to admire- that is what this programme is- a travelogue on French Gardens.
There is a book coming out in April
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Road-Le-Tholonet-Journey/dp/1471114570/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1360515996&sr=8-1
As for presenters this has been discussed here and elsewhere-I understand why a dislike is taken to some -not keen on Carole Klein-too gushy (sorry sacrilege broken) Alys Fowler too prissy-doesn't worry me much that a tool is thrown on the floor- we have all done that
I think with TB an experiment was made to make gardening the in-thing with a new audience it was not a complete failure after all-but you live with the presenter we have-MD will move on at some point
Beechgrove is more of a practical programme so with that and GW they will compliment not rival each other.
I agree Geoff. I watched just for the sheer plearsure of seeing a beautiful garden, whether it is to my taste or not. I admire the hard work and vision that has gone into the making of them. If you learn something along the way, all the better.
I agree too. There are too few gardening programmes (or even programmes about gardens) to moan about them when they come along. I prefer to just enjoy.
Au contraire - there are so few gardening programmes that the ones we have should be done well, from the initial idea to the setting of budgets, choosing of camera teams and editors, researching the gardens or subjects to be visited and final presentation. Monty's French Gardens is going out in a Friday night gardening slot so should be more than pretty pictures and a travelogue slapped together any old how. It should have some metaphorical gardening meat to it.
I've really enjoyed it so far - and Monty looks as though he's enjoying himself as well. I think it's a pity that there are so few things on TV about gardens - whether those to visit, or one's own garden and what to do/how to do it. I think there's room for more gardening related programmes, especially as there are so many TV channels these days - so can only conclude that The Powers That Be don't agree.
So... I know nothing and would like to suprise she who must be obeyed... Is there an idiot link or can someone point me in the direction of where each of these gardens are (Excluding Paris) so I can try and work it into my French holiday and become a god amongst men
Thanks in advance
Bit of a tall order-there is a book coming out -but not till April
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Road-Le-Tholonet-Journey/dp/1471114570/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1361998032&sr=8-1
If you read the summary on the Amazon page it gives you some locations-perhaps work from that??
I do know that Monets garden is at Giverney
There was a map of all the gardens in the GW magazine (Feb edition) - you might find one still in the shops. There are a group in Provence and another group in Normany and then the collection round Paris (Versailles et al).