Forum home Problem solving
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

How much builder's rubble is too much?

Hello there!

I'm building raised beds where there used to be a patio. Under the concrete slabs there's a fair bit of what I guess is builder's rubble: plenty of sand, and in places a seam of blue-grey powdery 'rock' that might be compacted cement powder? It's all very dense: before I went at it with a shovel, I wondered if some of the patio slabs had had a second layer of slabs beneath them! Beneath the rubble, it appears to be London clay, but even that is very compacted and in there I've found bits of plastic.

I'm planning to lay 12" of John Innes No. 3 above this, as I have plenty of mature plants in pots to put in. So my question is: should I remove everything I can? (It would be a lot of work, as it's a large raised be, but I'll do it if it's necessary!) Or perhaps I just need loosen it so that roots can grow through it? I'm hoping to plant a small tree in there, so ideally I'd want the roots to be able to go fairly far down.

Thanks in advance!

Posts

  • LoxleyLoxley Posts: 5,698
    I would break it up with a mattock to aid root penetration, but only really remove any huge chunks and old slabs etc, before laying topsoil. (I'd use topsoil with compost mixed in rather than JI no. 3 which is quite expensive).
    "What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbour". 
  • Thanks so much Loxley - that's really helpful. There ended up being a lot of surprisingly chunky bits to remove but it was good exercise and the bed is looking much healthier for it. And thanks for explaining re JI no. 3. I think I'll order premium planting loam from CPA?
Sign In or Register to comment.