Forum home Plants
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

Are these trees going to be too big?

Hi everyone,

We are currently planning our garden which is a blank canvas. I've been discussing it here https://forum.gardenersworld.com/discussion/1048950/garden-design-meltdown/p1

where you can see the size of the plot - not very big!

We'd like to plant some trees and like everything with gardening what seems like a simple task is turning out to be a bit trickier than thought.

We went to the garden centre yesterday and saw a lovely Acer - Sango Kaku and a Hawthorne Paul's Scarlet which also has potential but I'm worried about the size. The info on the Acer says it grows to 4m high x 2m spread after 20 years, which actually sounds pretty good. The Hawthorne is a little bigger 4m high x 4m spread after 20 years but up to 8m after 50 years. 

Can these trees be lopped successfully to stop them from growing too high?

In addition to an Acer what I'm ideally looking for is a tree in the corner of the garden, towards the back that grows to about twice the height of the fence 4-5m and  a spread of about 3-4m. Maybe planted within the grass to give it some growing room.

Any help would be appreciated.

Ed


Posts

  • Lizzie27Lizzie27 Posts: 12,494
    Hello Ed, I think both those trees would be okay. However the Acer needs shade as it will scorch in hot sunshine. It is a comparatively slow growing tree, one of mine has just reached the top of the fence after about 5 years so it might depend upon how long you intend to stay there. It does not like being pruned.
    The Hawthorn is good for wildlife, grows quicker, will lose its leaves in winter and has thorns. It is quite tough and can be pruned to size. Hope this helps. I'm sure other Posters will have their own suggestions.
    North East Somerset - Clay soil over limestone
  • Hi Lizzie, 

    Ahh yes you mentioned shade. I was going to say that the garden is facing south but the back fence is north facing. When the trees are small they will get some shade but when they clear the fence height it'll be full sun. Maybe the Acer wouldn't be best situated there then.
  • MY neighbour planted one in the corner of his garden. I have a great view of it from my landing window. Eventually it grew higher than our 7' hedge and as far as I can tell no harm has befallen it now it gets the prevailing wind and the sun from the south.
    Southampton 
  • ButtercupdaysButtercupdays Posts: 4,546
    The red leaved acers are a bit more tolerant.
    I have a Bloodgood planted where it gets plenty of wind and sun too , if we ever get any!
    It does ok, maybe not as well as if it were planted somewhere more to its liking, but not bad. It doesn't run short of water where it is though, which probably helps.
Sign In or Register to comment.