This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.
Garden type

Hi all,
Im wondering if my front garden fits a type which will help me plant more successfully.
It’s NW facing.
Large mature trees all around.
It borders my drive.
Soil is shallow. I’ve tried digging it up a few times but there is bricks etc only about six to nine inches down.
The “successful plants” are the pre-existing, mature (over ten years old) cherry laurel, rose bush, cotoneaster, spiraea japonica, berberis and a tree that needs coppicing.
Since Ive started gardening it only daffodils have really been successful, and some purple weed type things I’ve encouraged to spread. Sweet Williams looked well until I missed watering them.
Also successful but just appeared, not planted; lords & ladies, asaparagus.
What has *not* succeeded; a new rose bush, palm, bay tree, gladioli, lillies, nasturtium, heather, viola...more cherry laurel replanted saplings from the back garden.
Does any of this identify my garden or soil as a particular type?
Or is this all just not watering enough!
Im wondering if my front garden fits a type which will help me plant more successfully.
It’s NW facing.
Large mature trees all around.
It borders my drive.
Soil is shallow. I’ve tried digging it up a few times but there is bricks etc only about six to nine inches down.
The “successful plants” are the pre-existing, mature (over ten years old) cherry laurel, rose bush, cotoneaster, spiraea japonica, berberis and a tree that needs coppicing.
Since Ive started gardening it only daffodils have really been successful, and some purple weed type things I’ve encouraged to spread. Sweet Williams looked well until I missed watering them.
Also successful but just appeared, not planted; lords & ladies, asaparagus.
What has *not* succeeded; a new rose bush, palm, bay tree, gladioli, lillies, nasturtium, heather, viola...more cherry laurel replanted saplings from the back garden.
Does any of this identify my garden or soil as a particular type?
Or is this all just not watering enough!

0
Posts
PS - Be wary of lords & ladies - I let one self seed over 10 years ago and I'm still trying to get rid of them. Pretty but highly invasive
Billericay - Essex
Knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit.
Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad.
It's always good to think about foundations when you design a garden
Slowly permeable seasonally wet slightly acid but base-rich loamy and clayey soils
Loamy and clayey”
Does that match what’s happening in my post?
The back garden is fine. The front is the problem area. The L&L appeared this year, there’s tonnes of them under the surface - I just put a storage unit over them.
@zer@ZeroZero1
I could but I’m hoping to find a way forward as is, by figuring out what works there.
At a guess, your mature plants have their roots under the rubble, so it may only be either a thin layer or a discreet patch - like a filled ditch or a soakaway.
You could try digging a smallish hole - use a mattock and try to get through the rubble to see if it's a layer. If you can, then maybe plant things like a rose or cherry laurels if you want more of those, into the hole.
If you get down a way and are still in rubble, then try gently digging close to the roots of one of the established plants and see if it's in clear ground. If it is, start to dig back towards the rubbley bit and see if you find an edge. In that case you could plant bigger plants round the outside and plants that like very dry partial shade over the rubble.
Various attempts to plant trees have revealed a pattern in my garden. I managed to get hold of an old tythe map so I can now see that there used to be either tracks or hedge-banks crisscrossing the area close to the house, with a lot of close packed stones, about 5 feet wide. But beside the hedge/track is decent deep soil. So I have roses and shrubs to the side with euphorbia and geraniums in the stoney bits (it's probably sunnier than your garden). A horticulturist would probably be puzzled at the plants I have next to each other which really shouldn't grow side by side.
“It's still magic even if you know how it's done.”
Other things to think about. If you already have mature shrubs, the soil around it may be more drier and there may be extra shade around them too. You need to think more carefully about planting what is more suitable. A rose may not thrive because it's only young, or you have not planted it in deep enough. Just an example.