Forum home Plants
This Forum will close on Wednesday 27 March, 2024. Please refer to the announcement on the Discussions page for further detail.

Why has my Eucalyptus died , (and more)!!

Paul B3Paul B3 Posts: 3,154
  1. Visiting several gardens recently in the course of my work , I've been asked this question a number of times . Following the carnage caused by the two recent 'Beasts' , a number of the above have succumbed , whilst on the same road others have got through apparently unscathed .
  2. The answer lies with where the original seed of these trees was collected ; obviously seed originating from Eucalyptus gunnii growing at high altitude has adapted or evolved to withstand cold more easily than its more lower altitude counterparts . When asking :-"Is this plant hardy?" , the USDA hardiness index does not apply to cultivation in Western Europe , where the fickle and variable climate can cause havoc to plants from  more stable continental conditions . I once had a dismal attempt at growing Larix russica , or Siberian Larch . Destined to fail , it made an interesting experiment if nothing else ; mild weather in January would induce growth , only to be wrecked by treacherous Spring frosts year after year . Eventually it died , stunted and deformed ; yet this is a species capable of  tolerating down to -40C in Siberia .
  3. Not to say that positioning and aspect doesn't play a role in their survival .
  4. As we all know , every garden has its own microclimates ; one particular plant will grow there , and in another place will undoubtedly fail . A particularly windy or cold position will lead to the demise of an otherwise easy to grow species which will grow happily in a sheltered position . This applies in nature also , where plants of the same species have evolved several ecotypes , from low altitude meadows to almost alpine conditions , purely to  ensure their survival . Climatic extremes will probably kill hundreds of plants , but the toughest will survive . Speaking of 'extremes' , I have an Oroya laxiareolata ( a high altitude cactus from the Andes) ; its geometrically perfect golden-spined globes surviving at an altitude in nature of around 3800m above sea-level , exposed to an intensity of sunlight barely imaginable in our more benign lower conditions , yet this plant responds well to cultivation if treated correctly . I have a specimen of Blossfeldia , an olive-green skinned cactus which inhabits rock-crevices near mountain streams in S. America ; a mature plant only measures around 4cm diameter and bears delicate primrose-yellow flowers ; this happily co-exists  with the above under careful cultivation . I cannot help but be mildly amused when people attempt to grow cacti on windowsills . They 'survive' , owing purely to their resilience , but seldom thrive . A correctly grown plant should at least double its size and bodymass in a season .
  5. Species from very limited locations , or 'relic-populations' , are without doubt threatened with extinction in their native habitats . Metasequoias were only 'recently' rediscovered in the 1940s , known apparently only from fossils ; now widely cultivated in temperate climes , its future is probably safe . The giant redwoods of the Pacific NW coast were probably doomed before their value to landscaping was appreciated by garden designers .
  6. Going back to paragraph 2 , and plant adaptation , I have a Black Spruce (Picea mariana) from the NW USA ;this grows for about 6-weeks of the year from late May until the end of June . No amount of water , 'molly-coddling' or feeding alters its pre-ordained growth cycle . Completely adapted to a high-latitude short growth spurt.
  7. To 'sum it up ' ; grow as many species as you possibly can , attempt to learn of the plants origins and the conditions they experience in their habitats , and try as gardeners have done for generations to simulate these conditions to continue making British gardens possibly the envy of thw world . Good luck !! (Apologies for 'ranting').
  8. Oh well , time for bed ; work tomorrow !










Posts

  • WaysideWayside Posts: 845
    Great food for thought there.
  • Pat EPat E Posts: 12,316
    I haven’t read your whole post, but Eucalyptus pauciflora (Snow Gum) is hardy in our high country. Unfortunately it doesn’t have the round leaves of E. gunnii, which I suspect is why people like it, but the normal long or sickle shaped leaves of most Eucalyptus. If you want me to post a copy of a page of info from a book, I can. Otherwise try Mr Google.

    S. E. NSW
  • PosyPosy Posts: 3,601
    I live quite close to Ventnor Botanic Garden on the famous Undercliff. Sheltered from strong winds and frost, they grow all sorts of exotic plants, usually with success. It is an interesting place to visit and I believe it is fascinating to try out some unusual items in our own gardens, but I often wish plant labels were a little more honest. The catch-all 'well drained but moist in sun or part shade' seldom gives a full understanding of a plant's needs and weaknesses.
  • B3B3 Posts: 27,505
    'Moist,well-drained' always seems like an oxymoron to me :/
    In London. Keen but lazy.
  • PosyPosy Posts: 3,601
    I think they mean perfect, or perhaps impossible. Either way, my garden doesn't match up.
  • The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • fidgetbonesfidgetbones Posts: 17,618
    When we had the minus 15C frost here a few years ago, most of the Eucalyptus gunnii  around here died.  I have a Eucalyptus perriniana that I grew from seed about 25 years ago. It went in as a seedling, and despite being cut down a time or two, it is now 25 ft or so.  After the very hard winter,we thought it was going to die. It showed signs of stress and dropped quite a lot of leaves, but recovered.  It is supposed to  not be as hardy as E. gunnii.  My seed came from a tree grown at high altitude in Wales.  It is on the endangered list in Tasmania. Maybe the original stock is not so hardy, but seed produced in harder conditions  seems to be hardier.
  • Paul B3Paul B3 Posts: 3,154
    Posy
    Agree entirely ; more often than not the G/C staff themselves have no idea of the plants needs and weaknesses !
Sign In or Register to comment.